The 9/11 debate was centered on a single issue: Islam. Osama Bin Laden was taken at his own words by the West: Al-Qaeda, even if its methods were supposedly not approved by most Muslims, was seen as the vanguard or at least a symptom of “Muslim wrath” against the West… Then came, just ten years after 9/11, the Arab Spring, in which Islam did not play a role, and the killing of Osama Bin Laden, whose death went almost unnoticed among Muslim public opinion. What about the “Muslim wrath”? Suddenly, the issue of Islam and jihad being at the core of the political mobilization in Muslim societies seemed to become, at least for a time, irrelevant. So what went wrong with the perception of the Western media, leaders, and public opinion? Was the West wrong about the role of Islam in shaping political mobilization in Muslim societies? Yes. The essentialist and culturalist approach, common to both the clash of and dialogue of civilizations theories, missed three elements: society, politics, and more astonishingly . . . religion.Read the rest of The paradoxes of the re-Islamization of Muslim societies.
Olivier Roy is presently professor at the European University Institute (Florence) and heads there both the Mediterranean Programme and the ReligioWest project at the Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies. He is author of The Failure of Political Islam (Harvard University Press 1994), Globalized Islam (Columbia University Press 2004), and Holy Ignorance (Columbia University Press 2010).